Nemanja Vidic vs Virgil Van Dijk: Who has better stats in Premier League?

Both the defenders are arguably among the finest defenders to ever compete in the English top flight
Virgil van Dijk and Nemanja Vidic are arguably among the finest defenders to ever compete in the English Premier League. Throughout his eight-year tenure with Manchester United, Vidic was a titan.
Van Dijk was a standout at Southampton and has established himself as one of the top defenders in the world since joining Liverpool in 2018.
However, as per Liverpool legend Jamie Carragher, Van Dijk has had a better career at Liverpool so far he said on Twitter: VVD is far better than Vidic, who was a top CB, but have you forgotten his performances against Torres?"
When a Man United supporter questioned Carragher's viewpoint. "If you or anyone thinks Vidic is better than VVD you’re not watching the same game! He’s miles better!!"
In accordance with Carragher's assessment, football pundit Statman Dave calculated each player's Premier League statistics.
Even if statistics aren't everything, they imply there shouldn't be any discussion over which of the two players is superior.
Nemanja Vidic vs Virgil Van Dijk: Premier League stats

Virgil Van Dijk
Matches: 220
Clean sheets: 90
Goals conceded: 202
Premier League titles: 1
Nemanja Vidic
Matches: 211
Clean sheets: 95
Goals conceded: 133
Premier League titles: 5
Statistics from the Premier League favour Vidic above those of Van Dijk. Vidic managed to play in a few fewer matches for Manchester United than Van Dijk.
The Liverpool defender's numbers in England's top division are far inferior to those of the Serbian.
Also Read: Nemanja Vidic vs Fernando Torres: Record while playing against one another
In the majority of offensive metrics, Van Dijk triumphs. Compared to Vidic, he has more goals and assists despite winning a slightly better proportion of aerial duels.
Yet in every other measure, Vidic wins out.
The Serbian has a higher tackle rate of success, more last-man tackles, and more goal-line sweeps than the Liverpool star, who has committed more mistakes that have resulted in goals.
After earning a bachelor's degree in mass media, Rajarshi began his career as a sports writer in 2019, driven by his passion for sports journalism. He has been working in the field for over six years. A devoted fan of Lionel Messi and Barcelona, Rajarshi has been involved in sports since childhood. Before turning his focus to journalism, he even represented his college at the state level. Along with covering football, he enjoys playing the game, watching movies, and experimenting with new recipes in his spare time, as cooking is one of his favorite hobbies.
- Where and how to watch AFCON 2025 in UK?
- Morocco vs Comoros: Live streaming, TV channel, kick-off time & where to watch AFCON 2025
- Where and how to watch AFCON 2025 in India?
- Aston Villa vs Manchester United: Live streaming, TV channel, kick-off time & where to watch Premier League 2025-26
- Villarreal vs Barcelona: Live streaming, TV channel, kick-off time & where to watch LaLiga 2025-26
- AFCON 2025: All nations' squad list for Morocco
- Zlatan Ibrahimović names one of Lionel Messi’s sons as his “heir”
- GOD of cricket Sachin Tendulkar meets Lionel Messi, gifts his number '10' jersey at the Wankhede Stadium
- Top nine players Erling Haaland surpassed in Champions League goals; Henry, Rooney & more
- Top three highest bicycle kick goals in football history; Ronaldo, McTominay & more