India vs New Zealand Player Ratings: Finn Surman shines as Blue Tigers face 3-0 defeat against New Zealand
The Blue Tigers succumbed to a 3-0 loss
The Indian National Football Team suffered a 3-0 defeat against the New Zealand National Football Team on the 15th November, 2026 at the One New Zealand Stadium, Christchurch, as part of their FIFA International Friendly fixture.
Despite holding the game to a deadlock, the All Whites found their breakthrough in the 22nd minute, off Finn Surman. Following the first-half hydration break, the hosts scored two goals in quick succession, courtesy of James McGarry and Chris Wood, primarily coming off a defensive error from India, and at the stroke of half-time, the hosts walked into the tunnel with a 3-0 advantage.
In the second half, with the introduction of the changed centre-back duo of Bijoy and Pramveer, along with Hrithik Tiwari at the goal, the defence looked much more stable. The fresh legs, coupled with the drop in intensity in attack from New Zealand, helped to keep the scoreline at 3-0.
Here are the player ratings of the FIFA International Friendly match between India and New Zealand.
New Zealand Player Ratings (by Saikat Sengupta)
Catch Every Update, Anytime, Anywhere
Alex Paulsen – 7.5/10
The New Zealand custodian had another easy day at work as the Indian strikers failed to test him much. India tried creating some chances in the second half but it was well neutralised by the defence.
Francis De Vries – 7.5/10
De Vries, who was brilliant in the last game had another fairly decent game. He didn’t go as high press as he did against India in the last game, where he was seen making too many overlapping runs to set up Randall.
Michael Boxall – 8/10
The Minnesota United defender delivered a commanding performance at the back for New Zealand as they went on to keep yet another clean sheet.
Finn Surman – 8.5/10

The man who scored for New Zealand in the FIFA World Cup 2026 against Egypt scored the opener tonight for the hosts after a brilliant corner from McCowatt. It was a special moment for the Portland Timbers defender to score in the city where he was raised.
Owen Parker Price – 7/10
Almost every midfield battle in the game was won by Parker Price and New Zealand as the Indian midfield lacked that technical flair and were also physically outplayed.
Chris Wood – 8/10
The Nottingham Forest striker was heavily marked tonight and couldn’t find many openings but when he gets even a slim chance, he scores. A brilliant cross from Randall from the right flank saw Wood get an easy tap in to make it 3-0 for the hosts.
Matthew Garbett – 8/10
A brilliant link up play from Garbett and Randall saw Wood scoring the third for the hosts. He also came agonisingly close from scoring in the second half near the hour mark after missing the post by a few inches.
James McGarry – 8/10
Adding to the family total of his family, that has produces players previously for the New Zealand national team, McGarry scored the second goal for New Zealand with his left footer the ball hit the far post before finding the back of the net to make it 2-0.
Matthew Sheridan – 7/10
Sheridan was also brilliant from the flanks tonight with his accelerated runs upfront. India had a very few opening from the flanks and Sheridan’s recovery speed was also exceptional.
Callum McCowatt – 8.5/10
It was a brilliant corner from the number 10 that led to Surman finding the back of the net to help the hosts take a lead. Even the second goal for New Zealand came through a corner and McCowatt had been brilliant with his set pieces.
Jesse Randall – 7.5/10
The man who scored a brace in the last game gave an assist to Chris Wood after a lovely passage of attacking football with Garbett. He also offered positional versatility by switching flanks in the second half.
Substitutions:
Callan Elliot – 7/10
Elliot came alongside Walker and Bayliss near the hour mark. They rejuvenated the team and their fresh legs created too many chances upfront.
Nathan Walker – 7/10
The 20 year old striker could have been clinical upfront after coming on early.
Lachlan Bayliss – 8/10
Bayliss’ brilliant bit of skill saw New Zealand almost scoring the fourth goal after Hrithik Tiwari was caught off his position. He gave a brilliant cross and captain Rufer even headed it on target but Bijoy made a goal line clearance.
Logan Rogerson – 7/10
The right midfielder came in the last 15 minutes and had a few chances from the right flank.
Alex Rufer – 8/10
He came in for the last quarter and had a good spell, producing chances and giving dangerous crosses. He gave a brilliant cross to Piper who failed to head the ball on target. In the second attempt, he headed the ball on target before Varghese made a goal line clearance.
Corban Piper – 6.5/10
Piper missed a few easy chances to put the headers on target and make the score line over three for the All Whites.
India Ratings (by Niranjan R Prabhu)

Vishal Kaith – 3/10
Put a strong hand whenever the All Whites tried to breach the net. However, a silly mistake from the keeper gifted New Zealand the opener, after which two goals followed in quick succession. He was later substituted at the end of the first half. He was clearly not at his best today.
Tekcham Abhishek Singh – 4/10
Held the ball for too long in a few instances, ultimately leading to Abhishek losing control of the ball. He looked decent but at the same time was also beaten multiple times.
Overall, Abhishek had a patchy performance and was subbed off at break. He made individual mistakes but struggled overall because of the defensive structure.
Mehtab Singh – 5/10

Mehtab looked decent in the back and did pretty well to keep Randall silent during his attacks. Made good interventions whenever New Zealand tried to create agitation in the India box.
He made good use of the loose ball and took the first shot on target for India from outside the box in the 65th minute. He created some chances for India in the final minutes of the game.
Keeping the positives apart, Mehtab also made some bad clearances and fouls, even tackling his own keeper, which could have been costly and could have been better in communicating with his defenders.
Jay Gupta – 4/10
Neither blocked the cross or marked Chris Wood, leading to India conceding the third goal of the game. Was sluggish in defending sometimes but overall displayed a rather passable performance
Akash Mishra – 4.5/10

Initially, Mishra had a lack of communication with Sanan, and this led him to provide some wasteful long balls, gifting back possession to the All Whites. He could have done better to prevent the third goal and was substituted at the end of the first half. He had one of the more forgettable performances in an Indian shirt today.
Roshan Singh – 5/10
Played as a wing-back and displayed glimpses of his talent in defence with timely interceptions and even attempted to drive the ball forward, but was not able to create a significant impact in his long balls. Provided some good throw-ins and was also looking sharp throughout. He linked up decently with Ryan and was arguably among the better players for India.
Anirudh Thapa – 3/10

Looked shaky in the midfield. Struggled to hold the midfield together and did not provide any value addition to the team, relative to the other players and had a struggling performance.
Ashique Kuruniyan – 4/10

Failed to mark Finn Surman during a corner, paving the way for New Zealand to break the deadlock of the game. He was forced to play more inclined towards the right, despite being a left winger, significantly affecting his performance. He was replaced by Tomba in the second half. He was a better midfielder than others.
Mohammed Sanan – 4/10

Starting on the left, Sanan switched to the right flank as soon as India conceded the opener. However, he was unable to create a significant impact as the team collectively struggled to create any meaningful attack. Made some good clearances and interceptions in the defence whenever demanded. Was subbed off in the 58th minute for Suhail.
Manvir Singh – 3/10

Tried his luck to win the long balls delivered from the defensive half, but was beaten by the opponent defenders in almost every instance. Looked lazy, and this directly correlated with the number of final third entries by the Blue Tigers. The forward could have been more aware both defensively and offensively.
Ryan Williams – 4/10

India failed to attack, which meant Ryan had to spend most of the time in the defensive half and had to track back to win the ball and venture forward with it. Had decent game awareness and anticipated a few shots to defend them well.
In one instance, Ryan lacked decision-making as he held the ball rather than passing to Sanan, who was in a relatively better position to take a shot.
Substitutes
Pramveer – 4/10
Despite making some mistakes, Pramveer was not put into the test as much as he was in the last game, as the New Zealand players lacked intensity when the game approached the final minutes.
Bijoy Varghese – 6.5/10

Bijoy defended well with Pramveer, a combination which did not work well in the last game. Displayed his physicality and was able to beat the opponents with this dominance a couple of times. Made a crucial goal-line save to keep the score ticking at 3-0.
Hrithik Tiwari – 7/10
Made his national team debut and made some solid saves and claims when put to the test. Looked sharp and was excellent in his distribution and shot-stopping. Did well during the set pieces, which India struggled with in the first half and was the best player on the pitch for India.
Liston Colaco – 6/10
Made a good attack after coming in, which was probably the first real offensive initiative by the Blue Tigers till the 65th minute. He took a shot, which, despite being skied, was one of the only shots taken by India.
Suhail – 5.5/10

Suhail came on instead of Sanan and played his share to inject a relatively better attacking intent into the team.
Tomba Singh – 5.5/10

Took a long shot in the 76th minute, which, however, was a bad decision at the wrong time, as the midfielder had options to pass the ball and create an attack that could have been a bit more meaningful. However, had a positive impact as he tried to make things happen for India.
Hnamte – 5.5/10
Came in the second half, along with Tomba and Suhail, and did well to craft chances for India, something that was in drought during the first half.
David Lalhlansanga – 5/10
Came in the final minutes and looked decent during the final minutes of the game.
Fanai – 5/10
Similar to David, Fanai looked decent and did not make any individual mistakes.
What happened in the second International Friendly between India & New Zealand?
India suffered a 3-0 defeat against the New Zealand on the 15th November, 2026 at the One New Zealand Stadium, Christchurch, as part of their FIFA International Friendly fixture.
Who scored in the New Zealand vs India second international friendly?
Finn Surman, James McGarry and Chris Wood scored for New Zealand in their second international friendly against India.
For more updates, follow Khel Now on Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, Youtube; download the Khel Now Android App or IOS App and join our community on Whatsapp & Telegram.
