Mohun Bagan Super Giant vs Bengaluru FC Player Ratings: Jamie Maclaren, Vishal Kaith shine; Gurpreet Singh Sandhu disappoints in ISL 2024-25 Final

Gurpreet Singh Sandhu conceded a disappointing goal against the Mariners in ISL Final.

Mohun Bagan Super Giant won the 2024-25 Indian Super League (ISL) final in gritty fashion, with a 2-1 victory over Bengaluru FC at the Salt Lake Stadium, Kolkata on Saturday (12 April, 2025).

The visitors took a lead in the 49th minute through Alberto Rodriguez’s own goal, but goals from Jason Cummings (72’) and Jamie Maclaren (96’) helped the Mariners get the job done in extra time and complete the ISL double.

Here are the player ratings for the 2025 ISL Final:

Mohun Bagan Super Giant (by Uttiyo Sarkar)

Vishal Kaith – 8.0

Vishal was charged up and sharp in his goal for the final. Made some stellar saves from close-range shots, including brilliant one to deny Ryan Williams early in the second half. Couldn’t do much for the own goal.

Asish Rai – 6.5

Perhaps a bit too charged up by the occasion. Rai put in a lot of work, winning 10 duels and making four tackles! He was prone to the occasional errors because of shaky positioning, but got better as the game progressed.

Tom Aldred – 8.0

The Scottish defender held together a sturdy backline with his defensive work. He neutralized Edgar Mendes’ threat and came up with some vital challenges, winning 10 duels and making seven clearances.

Alberto Rodriguez – 5.0

Alberto had a pretty decent game apart form the own goal, winning many key duels. But he horribly misread a cross, unluckily putting the ball into the back of his own net.

Subhasish Bose – 7.0

The Mohun Bagan skipper was pretty sturdy, keeping Ryan Williams as quiet as possible. Ruined quite a few Bengaluru moves with his challenges, making seven possession recoveries and four blocks – including a goal line save.

Lalengmawia Ralte – 8.5

The 24-year-old was a really positive energy for his side in midfield. Couldn’t pass the ball around as frequently as he’d like, but worked hard to regain possession – winning 12 duels and making three tackles.

Anirudh Thapa – 4.0

Struggled in the intense midfield battle. Lost more duels (4) than he won (1), lost possession quite a few times and failed to add any creative thrust.

Manvir Singh – 6.0

Manvir troubled Bengaluru with his speedy forward runs at times, but his final product was a bit awry. Had a shot go wide in the second half and couldn’t create much despite troubling Roshan at times.

Jason Cummings – 7.0

Cummings had a quiet first hour, not being able to do much. However, he leapt into life to make the cross that helped to win the penalty before dispatching it with an excellent spot-kick.

Liston Colaco – 4.5

Colaco failed to really impose himself in the game, only making six passes. He made some nice defensive contributions, but failed to create anything noteworthy or test the goalkeeper.

Jamie Maclaren – 7.0

Maclaren won his side the penalty by flicking a ball at Chinglensana’s arm. Apart from that, he struggled to trouble the visitors. His meek attempts in normal time were saved, but he made up for his poor outing with a brilliant finish early in extra time.  

Substitutes

Ashique Kuruniyan – 6.0

Kuruniyan added more energy to his side’s attacking thrust with his darting forward runs. His crossing, however, was a mixed-bag. Bust into the box with a nice run in the 89th minute, but his shot was saved.

Sahal Abdul Samad – 6.0

Helped add more pressure to the Bengaluru backline by being a troublesome figure in the final third. Few of his shots were well wide of the mark.

Greg Stewart – 6.5

Stewart added more incisiveness for his side, making a smart forward pass in the box to trigger Maclaren’s goal.

Deepak Tangri – 6.0

Helped add more steel to his side’s midfield in extra time, helping them defend their lead strongly.

Dimitri Petratos – N/R

Made a few nice runs on the counter-attacks.

ALSO READ: ISL 2024-25 Final: Edgar Mendez calls out refereeing discrepancies during summit clash

Bengaluru FC Player Ratings – (By Preethi)

Gurpreet Singh Sandhu – 6

While Gurpreet only had four saves to make throughout the game, he was ultimately unable to prevent the penalty, marking a key moment in a crucial game like this. A costly mistake from him allowed Maclaren to score the second goal against Bengaluru FC.

Namgyal Bhutia – 7

Bhutia was highly effective as the right-back, putting in a strong defensive performance. It was a setback for the team when he had to be taken off due to injury.

Rahul Bheke – 6.5

Considering his significant experience and the leadership qualities he often displays, Rahul Bheke’s performance fell short of expectations in this game.

Chinglensana singh – 6

Sana had a fairly decent game defensively with his timely clearances but an unfortunate error resulted in Mohun Bagan getting a penalty.

Naorem Roshan Singh – 6.5

Roshan delivered a strong performance, effectively contributing to the defense with numerous clearances and tackles, resulting in a good performance.

Pedro Capo – 6

Pedro Capo had an average showing throughout the match, which also saw him get booked with a yellow card for a foul on Sahal.

Alberto Noguera – 7.5

Alberto Noguera was a tireless presence in the midfield, He was a constant attacking threat, consistently creating chances and effectively controlling the tempo and possession.

Suresh Singh Wangjam – 6.5

Making his return to the pitch after recovering from a minor injury, Suresh delivered a strong and impactful performance in the midfield, showing his importance to the team.

Sunil Chhetri – 7

Sunil Chhetri was actively involved in creating numerous scoring opportunities but was ultimately unable to convert any of them into goals.

Edgar Mendez -7

Edgar Mendez was a physical presence throughout the match and showed a  desire to score, but his efforts didn’t changee into any concrete opportunities.

Ryan Williams – 7.5

Ryan Williams was a tireless presence, constantly running across the pitch and creating a lot of chances for his team.Despite not converting any of these chances, he registered the highest top speed of the game.

Substitutions

Lalremtluanga Fanai – 6.5

Stepping in for the injured Bhutia at the 60th minute and later adapting to a midfield role after Salah’s substitution, the young Fanai showed a very good level of confidence trying to create chances even in the final few moments.

Jorge Pereyra Diaz – 6

Despite his efforts to unlock the defense and create chances, Pereyra Diaz came in for Edgar Mendez at the 68th minute also found himself in the referee’s books, receiving a yellow card

Mohamad Salah – NA

Given his limited time on the pitch, Salah who replaced Suresh Singh Wangjam at the 91st minute managed to put in a decent performance

Sivasakti Narayan – NA

With only moments left on the game, Sivasakti’s introduction was too late for him to have any real impact on the game. Additionally he also received a yellow card.

Vinith Venkatesh – NA

Introduced in the final stages of the match, Vinith barely had a chance to get involved and thus had no real impact

For more updates, follow Khel Now on Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, Youtube; download the Khel Now Android App or IOS App and join our community on Whatsapp & Telegram.