Top 10 footballers who moved to arch-rival clubs
Luis Figo was welcomed with utmost hostility at Camp Nou as Barca fans threw a ‘pig head’ at him.
In football, loyalty is a sacred covenant between a player and their supporters, an unspoken bond rooted in passion and allegiance. But when that bond is severed, when a player switches allegiances to a rival club, it is often seen as the ultimate act of betrayal, a sin akin to treason in the eyes of ardent fans. These transfers can ignite tempers, fuel rivalries, and sometimes even lead to dramatic incidents, such as the infamous pig’s head thrown onto the pitch for Luís Figo when he made his contentious move from FC Barcelona to Real Madrid.
Such seismic shifts in footballing allegiance are not just about contracts or offers; they encapsulate the volatile emotions and tribalism that define the beautiful game. In this article, we explore the stories of some legendary players who dared to tread this perilous path, crossing the chasm between arch-rival clubs and leaving an indelible mark on football history. From the likes of Robert Lewandowski, who moved from Borussia Dortmund to Bayern Munich, to Sol Campbell, whose transfer from Tottenham Hotspur to Arsenal still stirs resentment, we unravel tales of ambition, courage, and controversy.
This journey will take us through the rivalries that define football’s fiercest clashes, exploring how these players not only faced backlash but also proved their mettle on the field. Their decisions were fraught with risk, yet they carved out legacies that continue to provoke debate and admiration.
10. Nick Barnby (Everton to Liverpool)
Nick Barmby’s career was marked by immense talent and a knack for stirring controversy, particularly due to his infamous switch between Merseyside rivals Everton and Liverpool. Born in Hull, the English attacking midfielder first gained recognition at Tottenham Hotspur, where he honed his craft before moving to Everton in 1996. At Goodison Park, Barmby quickly became a fan favourite, making 116 appearances and scoring 18 goals during his four-year stint. His creativity and flair made him one of the Toffees’ most prized assets, solidifying his place as one of the most pivotal players of the late 1990s.
However, in a move that shocked and enraged Everton fans, Barmby turned down a lucrative offer from Everton to make the short but seismic switch to Liverpool in 2000. Joining the Reds was seen as an unforgivable betrayal, and his reception at Goodison Park turned hostile overnight. At Liverpool, Barmby made 32 appearances and scored two goals. Although his contributions on the pitch were modest, he was part of a historic treble-winning squad in 2001 that claimed the UEFA Cup, FA Cup, and FA Charity Shield.
The defining moment of his controversial transfer came when he donned the Liverpool shirt in the fierce Merseyside Derby. In a match against his former club, Barmby scored in the 12th minute and celebrated exuberantly in front of the Anfield faithful. The sight of their former hero revelling in a goal against them deeply angered Everton fans, cementing his status as a figure of animosity on the blue side of Merseyside.
9. Ashley Cole (Arsenal to Chelsea)
Ashley Cole’s transfer from Arsenal to Chelsea remains one of the most contentious moves in Premier League history, forever tarnishing his legacy among Arsenal supporters. Born and raised in London, the English left-back began his journey with Arsenal’s youth academy and emerged as one of the best defenders of his generation. Over nearly a decade, he became an indispensable part of Arsène Wenger’s iconic “Invincibles” squad, winning two Premier League titles and three FA Cups.
However, behind the scenes, tensions between Cole and Arsenal began to simmer. In the months leading up to his departure, Cole claimed that individuals within the club’s management were intent on severing ties with him. Initially, he insisted that he could never imagine playing against Arsenal in the Premier League and hinted at a preference for moving abroad. Yet, what unfolded shocked fans and the footballing world alike: Cole not only stayed in England but also joined Chelsea, Arsenal’s bitter cross-town rivals, in 2006.
The move, reportedly driven by disputes over wages, earned him the derisive nickname “Cashley” among Arsenal fans, who viewed his decision as a betrayal of the club’s philosophy and values. At Chelsea, however, Cole thrived, becoming a key figure in a golden era for the Blues. Over the course of 229 appearances, he won the Premier League, four FA Cups, the UEFA Champions League, and the Europa League, solidifying his status as one of the greatest left-backs in football history.
8. Mario Gotze (Borussia Dortmund to Bayern Munich)
Mario Götze, the German playmaker from Memmingen, rose to prominence as one of the most gifted players of his generation, earning accolades for his technical brilliance and footballing intelligence. After honing his skills at Borussia Dortmund’s academy, Götze made his senior debut in 2009, quickly establishing himself as a linchpin in Jürgen Klopp’s vibrant and youthful squad. Over four years, he made 83 Bundesliga appearances, scoring 22 goals and playing a crucial role in Dortmund’s back-to-back Bundesliga triumphs in 2010-11 and 2011-12.
However, Götze’s announcement of a move to arch-rivals Bayern Munich in April 2013, just before Dortmund’s UEFA Champions League semi-final clash against Real Madrid, sent shockwaves through the footballing world and infuriated the Dortmund faithful. The €37 million transfer, which activated Götze’s release clause, was seen as a betrayal by the fans who had idolized him as a homegrown prodigy and a symbol of the club’s resurgence.
The timing of the announcement compounded the backlash, with Dortmund fans venting their anger during training sessions and matches. Security measures were heightened to protect Götze from potential threats, highlighting the depth of the animosity. Even Jürgen Klopp, known for his unflinching support of his players, admitted that the decision’s timing was far from ideal, particularly during such a pivotal moment in the club’s history.
7. Zlatan Ibrahimovic (Juventus to Inter Milan)
Zlatan Ibrahimović, a footballing maverick renowned for his audacious personality and unparalleled skill, remains one of the most polarizing figures in the sport’s history. Hailing from Malmö, Sweden, Zlatan’s rise to prominence began with Ajax, where his flair and goal-scoring abilities set him apart. In 2004, he made a high-profile move to Juventus, where his contributions were crucial, scoring 23 goals in 70 appearances and earning individual accolades as he established himself as one of Europe’s premier forwards.
However, Ibrahimović’s reputation as a controversial figure was solidified during Juventus’s darkest hour. In 2006, the Calciopoli scandal shook Italian football to its core, and Juventus, found guilty of match-fixing, faced relegation to Serie B. While some Juventus players, such as Alessandro Del Piero, Gianluigi Buffon, and Pavel Nedved, stayed to rebuild the club, Zlatan opted to leave. His move to arch-rivals Inter Milan, a club that benefited greatly from Juventus’s fall, was viewed as a betrayal by the Turin faithful.
At Inter, Zlatan thrived, leading the Nerazzurri to three consecutive Serie A titles (2006-07, 2007-08, 2008-09). His dazzling performances, coupled with his knack for scoring spectacular goals, cemented his place as one of the finest strikers in Serie A history. Yet, for Juventus supporters, his decision to abandon the club during its most vulnerable period was seen as an unforgivable act of disloyalty.
While Zlatan went on to achieve greatness with several clubs across Europe, including Barcelona, AC Milan, Paris Saint-Germain, and Manchester United, his controversial move from Juventus to Inter remains a defining moment in his storied career. It underscored both his commitment to personal ambition and his willingness to make contentious decisions, hallmarks of a player who has always prioritized success over sentiment.
6. Gonzalo Higuain (Napoli to Juventus)
Gonzalo Higuaín, the 37-year-old striker born in Brest, France, carved a prolific career with clubs such as River Plate and Real Madrid before joining Napoli in 2013. At Napoli, he became an icon, netting 71 goals in 104 appearances and playing a pivotal role in their triumphs in the Coppa Italia and Supercoppa Italiana in 2014. However, his legacy in Naples took a dramatic turn in 2016 when he made the controversial move to Juventus, a bitter rival of Napoli.
This transfer was viewed as an unforgivable betrayal by Napoli fans, sparking widespread animosity. According to the New York Times, local restaurants in Naples even offered discounts if Higuaín suffered an injury while playing for Juventus. The outrage was so intense that one rapper created a chorus declaring, “I’ll enjoy myself once Higuaín dies,” reflecting the extreme sentiments of disillusioned fans.
Despite the hostility, Higuaín showcased his brilliance at Juventus, winning three Serie A titles and playing a key role in their journey to the UEFA Champions League final in the 2016-17 season. While his transfer remains one of the most contentious in Italian football history, his achievements at Juventus cemented his place as one of the era’s most talented strikers.
5. Roberto Baggio (Fiorentoina to Juventus)
Roberto Baggio, the iconic Italian attacking midfielder hailing from Caldogno, is often celebrated for his remarkable skill and elegance on the pitch. Baggio began his professional journey with Vicenza before rising to prominence at Fiorentina, where he spent nearly five years. During his tenure in Florence, he became a fan favourite, scoring 39 goals in 94 appearances and establishing himself as one of the most gifted players of his generation.
However, his storied relationship with Fiorentina came to a dramatic and controversial end in 1990 when he made the seismic decision to join Juventus, Fiorentina’s arch-rival, for a then-record transfer fee of $11 million. The announcement sent shockwaves through Florence, igniting mass riots and civil disobedience. Fiorentina fans, enraged by what they perceived as a betrayal, took to the streets, hurling stones and bricks in protest.
The fury reached such a boiling point that Flavio Pontello, Fiorentina’s president at the time, was forced to seek refuge by barricading himself in a secure location. The relentless backlash and escalating tensions ultimately compelled Pontello to sell the club for his safety. Despite the hostility, Baggio maintained a sense of loyalty to his former club, famously refusing to take a penalty against Fiorentina while wearing Juventus colours, a gesture that endeared him to Fiorentina fans, even in the face of profound betrayal.
4. Ronaldo (FC Barcelona to Real Madrid and AC Milan to Inter Milan)
Ronaldo Luís Nazário de Lima, widely hailed as “O Fenomeno,” remains one of football’s greatest-ever talents, renowned not only for his extraordinary goal-scoring prowess but also for his controversial moves between arch-rival clubs. His meteoric rise took him to PSV Eindhoven, where he solidified his reputation as a prodigious talent by scoring 54 goals in 58 appearances.
In 1996, Ronaldo joined FC Barcelona, where he had arguably the most electrifying season of his career. With an astonishing 34 goals in 37 appearances across all competitions, he became the youngest player to win the FIFA World Player of the Year award. Despite his brilliance, a contract dispute led to his departure to Inter Milan in 1997, where he continued to shine, scoring 49 goals in 68 appearances and claiming another FIFA World Player of the Year title. During his time at Inter, he became a global icon, yet injuries began to plague his career.
The most contentious chapter of Ronaldo’s journey came in 2002, when he joined Real Madrid during the height of the Galácticos era, leaving behind his ties with Barcelona. At Madrid, Ronaldo became a fan favourite, scoring 104 goals in 177 appearances and helping the club secure the 2002-03 LaLiga title. Despite his injuries, his innate talent and charisma kept him at the forefront of footballing greatness.
In another shocking twist, Ronaldo joined AC Milan in 2007, crossing the fierce divide after his tenure at Inter. Although his time at Milan was curtailed by injuries, he still managed to display glimpses of his genius. His decision to play for Milan further solidified his reputation as a player who thrived amid controversy and fierce rivalries.
3. Johan Cryuff (Ajax to Feyenoord)
Johan Cruyff, the Dutch maestro from Amsterdam, is widely regarded as one of football’s greatest innovators and legends. Rising through the ranks at Ajax, Cruyff became synonymous with the club’s golden years during the 1960s and 1970s. Over his illustrious first stint with Ajax, he made 245 appearances and scored a staggering 193 goals, playing a pivotal role in revolutionizing the game with his artistry and vision. His influence was instrumental in Ajax clinching eight Eredivisie titles and establishing themselves as a dominant force in European football.
After his remarkable tenure with Ajax, Cruyff embarked on new challenges with Barcelona and Los Angeles Aztecs, showcasing his genius on different stages. However, he eventually returned to Ajax for a second spell, bringing experience and leadership to the club. Yet, his second stint ended in an unexpected and unceremonious fashion, as the club decided against renewing his contract.
In a move that stunned the footballing world, Cruyff switched allegiances to Ajax’s bitter rivals, Feyenoord, for the 1983-84 season. Despite the controversy surrounding his transfer, Cruyff’s brilliance shone once again. In just one season with Feyenoord, he made 33 appearances, scoring 11 goals and serving as a transformative figure for the team. His impact was monumental, leading Feyenoord to a domestic double by securing the Eredivisie title and the KNVB Cup.
For his phenomenal contributions that season, Cruyff was honoured with the Dutch Footballer of the Year award, cementing his legacy as a player whose influence transcended club rivalries. His Feyenoord chapter remains a testament to his enduring genius and ability to defy expectations.
2. Sol Campbell (Tottenham to Arsenal)
Sol Campbell, one of the most commanding English centre-backs of his era, began his illustrious footballing journey at Tottenham Hotspur. Born in London, Campbell rose through the Spurs youth ranks, eventually becoming a stalwart at White Hart Lane. Over nearly a decade, he made 255 appearances and scored 10 goals, solidifying his reputation as a club legend and fan favourite.
However, in a move that shocked the footballing world, Campbell crossed one of football’s fiercest divides in July 2001 by joining Tottenham’s arch-rivals, Arsenal. The transfer came after Campbell famously stated that such a move would infuriate Spurs fans, making his eventual switch to the Gunners all the more controversial.
The announcement was so unexpected that Arsène Wenger, then Arsenal’s manager, later admitted that only two journalists attended the press conference, unaware of the bombshell revelation awaiting them. Campbell’s decision ignited outrage among Spurs supporters, who felt deeply betrayed by a player they had once idolized.
Despite the backlash, Campbell thrived at Arsenal, playing a pivotal role in the club’s success during his tenure. He became an integral part of Wenger’s legendary “Invincibles” squad, which went unbeaten throughout the 2003-04 Premier League season. His time with Arsenal cemented his legacy as one of English football’s greats, but the sting of his move still lingers in the memories of Tottenham fans.
1. Luis Figo (Barcelona to Real Madrid)
Luis Figo’s transfer from Barcelona to Real Madrid remains one of the most controversial and incendiary moves in the annals of football history. The Portuguese maestro from Almada rose to prominence with Sporting CP before joining Barcelona in 1995. At Camp Nou, Figo became a symbol of class and creativity, making 172 appearances and netting 30 goals. His stellar performances helped Barcelona secure two LaLiga titles, two Copa del Rey trophies, and the UEFA Super Cup in 1997, earning him adoration from the Catalan faithful.
However, his status as a Barcelona icon was obliterated in July 2000 when he orchestrated a shocking transfer to their eternal rivals, Real Madrid, for a then-record fee of €62 million. The move was seen as the ultimate betrayal by Barcelona fans, who had idolized him as one of their own. The fallout was swift and ferocious.
The animosity reached its zenith when Figo returned to Camp Nou wearing the white of Real Madrid. The atmosphere was hostile beyond measure, with the crowd hurling projectiles that included coins, glass bottles, and the now-infamous pig’s head, an enduring symbol of their disdain. Banners emblazoned with words like “Traitor” and “Judas” adorned the stadium, encapsulating the fury of a betrayed fanbase.
This transfer and its aftermath epitomize the intense emotional bond between fans and their clubs, as well as the volatility that can arise when that bond is perceived to be shattered. While Figo went on to achieve immense success with Real Madrid, including LaLiga titles, Spanish Super Cups, UEFA Champions League title and a Ballon d’Or in 2000, his move remains a cautionary tale of how loyalty or the lack thereof can forever alter a player’s legacy.
For more updates, follow Khel Now on Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram; download the Khel Now Android App or IOS App and join our community on Telegram.
- Wolves' all-time Premier League top scorers
- Kerala Blasters' T.G. Purushothaman highlights performances of these players after win against Mohammedan SC
- Arsenal's Bukayo Saka likely to be out for several weeks with hamstring injury
- How Premier League clubs fare after finishing top at Christmas? Liverpool, Arsenal, Man City & more
- Top 10 greatest football matches of all time
