Top four Everton players with most Premier League goals

The Toffees have had many well-known players in their history.

Who are Everton’s top scorers in the Premier League era? They are one of the most well-known teams in English football.

Seeing who has contributed the most to the Toffees at this time is intriguing. However, none of the players have been able to hit the 100-goal mark in the league, but they remain etched in the annals of the club with their contribution.

The club have given supporters some of the greatest games, memories, and players over the past thirty years, despite never taking home the Premier League championship.

Players with most goals scored for Everton in Premier League

4. Tim Cahill: 56 PL goals

Tim Cahill, who played for Everton for eight seasons from 2004–05 to 2011–12, is one of the team’s most adored players of the last several years. The Australian had an eye (or head) for a goal, was dependable, hardworking, and tough as nails. Additionally, his popularity was unaffected by his frequent goals against Liverpool.

At one point, he scored nine goals in a row with his head, making him one of the greatest headers of a ball in Premier League history, given his height. This made him an auxiliary/makeshift centre forward as well as an attacking midfielder.

3. Dominic Calvert-Lewin: 57 PL goals

Calvert-Lewin, known more for fashion shoots and frequent injuries than goals in recent seasons, had two outstanding seasons with Everton in 2019–20 (13 goals) and 2020–21 (16 goals), the latter of which began with goals in five straight games. At one point, he appeared to be the next great English number nine.

After this prolific goal-scoring phase, the striker suffered frequent injuries that continued to impact his goal-scoring ability. But the forward is still among the top scorers for Everton in the league.

2. Duncan Ferguson: 60 PL goals

He won the FA Cup, scored in double digits in two seasons, and became the first player to score a hat-trick of headers during his first stint with the team (1994–1995), which was filled with ups and downs.

After returning to Everton in 2000, Ferguson became more of a battering ram. His most well-known goal came in 2005 against Manchester United.

He remained one of the league’s most feared players, which made the fans even more fond of him. He continues to hold the record for the only Scottish player to score the most goals in Premier League history.

1. Romelu Lukaku: 68 PL goals

Despite being one of the most vilified players of his generation, Romelu Lukaku’s tenure on Merseyside is undeniable. From 2013–14 to 2016–17, he scored 68 goals in just four seasons, the first of which was on loan before being acquired in a then-club record deal.

Given that the Belgian striker has the two-best goal-scoring seasons for Everton in Premier League history—18 and 25, goals respectively—and that the latter total also earned him a spot in the PFA Team of the Year, it was money well spent.

Most Premier League goals scored for Everton:◎ 68 – Romelu Lukaku◎ 60 – Duncan Ferguson ◉ 57 – Dominic Calvert-Lewin ◎ 56 – Tim Cahill After scoring just three goals in 1,614 mins of PL action in 24/25, it's time for a new challenge for DCL. 🍬 pic.twitter.com/oIb6TsgAh7

— Squawka (@Squawka) June 29, 2025

For more updates, follow Khel Now on Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram; download the Khel Now Android App or IOS App and join our community on Telegram.