Fact Check: Is Carlito only Judgment Day member to competed in WWE Judgment Day PLE?

Judgment Day is one of the top heel factions in the active WWE roster!
WWE Judgment Day was one of the annual pay-per-views hosted by WWE from 1998 to 2008, however was replaced by Over the Limit in 2010 and the event was discontinued. However, the WWE reused the stable name The Judgment Day in 2022.
The Judgment Day is one of the most dominating, top heel factions of the active WWE roster for over the last two years. The Rated ‘R’ Superstar Edge founded the villainous faction with Damian Priest and Rhea Ripley. However the addition of Finn Balor ended Edge’s tenure in the faction and also became the leaderless faction. Dominik Mysterio and JD McDonagh joined the faction to make it a five people stable and they achieved great success.
However the internal tensions within the faction and as a result of Liv Morgan’s revenge tour Damian Priest and Rhea Ripley got kicked out of the faction. Liv Morgan and Carlito replaced them and the new faction remains a five member crew. With the addition of Carlito in the faction, an online fan states that he is the only member of the current Judgment Day, who competed in a Judgment Day PPV. Here is a quick fact check on the statement.
Is Carlito the only Judgment Day member to compete in Judgment Day PPV?
Yes, Carlito is the only current Judgment Day member to be a part of the Judgment Day pay-per-view. The Caribbean Cool has featured in two pay-per-view series.
In 2005, Carlito faced Big Show in a singles match and won the match with the help of Matt Morgan. He also appeared on the 2008 edition of the PPV series, where he teamed up with Santino Marella and challenged Hardcore Holly & Cody Rhodes for the World Tag Team Championship, but failed. With this the Carlito becomes the only current member to have an exposure to Judgment Day before the faction.
When it comes to all of previous Judgment Day members, Edge featured in a total of five Judgment Day pay-per-views in total and has also main evented the final Judgment Day pay-per-view in 2009.
What’s your thoughts on the current storyline angle of Judgment Day? Share your thoughts in the comments section below.
For more updates, follow Khel Now on Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram; download the Khel Now Android App or IOS App and join our community on Telegram.

Where passion meets insight — blending breaking news, in-depth strategic analysis, viral moments, and jaw-dropping plays into powerful sports content designed to entertain, inform, and keep you connected to your favorite teams and athletes. Expect daily updates, expert commentary and coverage that never leaves a fan behind.
- Top three WWE championships Naomi can cash-in for her Money in the Bank contract
- Top four stars who could challenge Gunther at WWE Night of Champions 2025
- Top three superstars who could be mystery man in WWE King of the Ring Tournament
- Sheamus possibly reveals mystery man for WWE King of the Ring 2025 tournament
- Who is Mr Iguana? AAA star set to join WWE main roster