Who chose Pat McAfee as Randy Orton’s Mystery Caller on WWE SmackDown? Backstage details revealed
(Courtesy : WWE)
Pat McAfee has aligned with Randy Orton ahead of WrestleMania 42!
Pat McAfee was revealed as Randy Orton’s mystery caller on WWE SmackDown (April 3, 2026), attacking Cody Rhodes in St. Louis. Reports indicate TKO CEO Ari Emanuel, not Triple H or WWE creative, decided to insert McAfee into the WrestleMania 42 feud, believing the ESPN personality would elevate the program and boost ticket sales.
Pat McAfee made a shocking return to WWE on the April 3 episode of SmackDown, attacking Cody Rhodes and revealing himself as the mystery person who has been guiding Randy Orton’s recent heel run. The ESPN personality appeared in Orton’s hometown of St. Louis wearing an RKO t-shirt, delivering a low blow to the Undisputed WWE Champion before cutting a scathing promo about the current state of the company.
However, the bigger story may be happening behind the scenes. According to multiple reports, the decision to bring McAfee into the Rhodes vs Orton feud did not originate from WWE’s creative team.
Who decided to bring in Pat McAfee?
The decision to insert Pat McAfee into the Randy Orton and Cody Rhodes storyline came from TKO leadership, specifically CEO Ari Emanuel, according to sources cited by PWInsider and BodySlam. The directive was then approved by Triple H rather than originating from the WWE creative team.
PWInsider reported that there is a strong belief within WWE that this was not a call from Chief Content Officer Paul “Triple H” Levesque or the creative room. Instead, it came directly from Ari Emanuel and TKO brass, with Triple H signing off on the decision after it was made above his level.
What happened?
The mystery caller reveal kicked off Friday’s SmackDown when Cody Rhodes confronted Randy Orton in the ring. As the two began brawling, McAfee entered from behind and attacked Rhodes with a low blow.
While Orton destroyed Rhodes with a steel chair, McAfee grabbed the microphone and explained his actions. He criticized WWE’s current direction, complained about having to watch undersized wrestlers, and mentioned SmackDown’s recent ratings struggles.
McAfee declared that Orton was going to “save the business” and confirmed he was the voice pushing The Viper to embrace his darker instincts.
Why did TKO want Pat McAfee in this feud?
Ari Emanuel believes Pat McAfee is a star who will help elevate the Orton-Rhodes program between his ESPN show and weekly SmackDown episodes before WrestleMania, according to BodySlam’s report. The decision appears to be part of TKO’s strategy to use mainstream names to boost viewership and ticket sales.
WrestleMania 42 ticket sales have been slower than expected. As of April 1, just over 38,000 tickets had been sold for Night One and roughly 40,000 for Night Two, both well behind last year’s figures at Allegiant Stadium.
McAfee’s recent comments about the wrestling business having passed him by were reportedly kayfabe, with his return being planned for weeks as part of TKO’s push to bring celebrity involvement into major storylines.
Who is Randy Orton’s mystery caller on WWE SmackDown?
Pat McAfee is Randy Orton’s mystery caller. The ESPN personality and former WWE commentator was revealed on the April 3, 2026, episode of SmackDown in St. Louis, Missouri, when he attacked Cody Rhodes and aligned himself with Orton heading into WrestleMania 42.
Did Triple H approve Pat McAfee joining the feud?
Yes, Triple H approved the decision, but reports indicate the directive to bring Pat McAfee into the storyline came from TKO CEO Ari Emanuel and TKO brass, not from WWE’s creative team. Triple H signed off on the decision after it was made at the executive level.
When does Randy Orton face Cody Rhodes at WrestleMania 42?
Randy Orton challenges Cody Rhodes for the Undisputed WWE Championship in the main event of Night One of WrestleMania 42 on April 18, 2026, at Allegiant Stadium in Las Vegas, Nevada. The event takes place over two nights, April 18 and 19.
For more updates, follow Khel Now Wrestling on Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram; download the Khel Now Android App or IOS App and join our community on Telegram & Whatsapp.
Blesson Daniel is a sub-editor who spends his days organizing words and managing social media, crafting bursts of creativity designed to make people smile. He occasionally dives into writing as well — whether it’s crafting articles, brainstorming ideas, or finding the perfect caption. Believing that every piece of writing offers an opportunity to tell a story, Blesson brings creativity and thoughtfulness to every project he takes on. When he’s not glued to his laptop, Blesson is likely planning his next travel adventure or losing himself in music. A passionate explorer of new places, sounds, and ideas, he believes in balancing work, play, and a good playlist in the background. Whether he’s editing, writing, or daydreaming about his next trip, Blesson is always chasing that sweet spot where creativity and curiosity collide to create something memorable.