FC Goa demand greater accountability from AIFF over refereeing errors
The Gaurs lost their first match of the ISL 2026-27 season against Bengaluru FC
FC Goa lost to Bengaluru FC on Friday in their match during the Indian Football League (ISL) 2026-27 campaign after officials missed a basic call. During the post-match presentation, FC Goa skipper Sandesh Jhingan didn’t hesitate to point out the error.
Afterwards the club did something more consequential than a post match interview comment. The Gaurs made the decision to formally write to the AIFF Referees’ Department, the AIFF Secretariat and the league.
The club said its concerns were “not about any single decision or result”, but about a season-long pattern involving basic decisions, consistency, and the preparation given to officials, particularly those new to the league.
What triggered the response
Catch Every Update, Anytime, Anywhere
The immediate trigger was a chaotic finish. Deep in stoppage time, Malsawmsanga went down in Bengaluru’s box under a challenge from Rickey Meetei, and referee Pratik Mondal waved away the appeal. Additionally, Malsawmsanga was booked following it.
The throw-in instance is the second trigger. FC Goa were given a throw-in, but the officials failed to agree with FC Goa, who were entitled to it. Bengaluru restarted despite replays suggesting the ball had last touched a Bengaluru player. Soham Varshneya scored in the 90+3rd minute to win the game, which was only possible from the throw-in. The call was not subtle or subjective, and a basic restart was called wrong.
The Demands set by the Gaurs
As reported, the club wants the AIFF to respond with concrete measures and visible improvements. Per the brief, the proposals fall into four areas:
- Transparency and accountability. Clubs currently have no visible way to learn whether a clear mistake leads to review, correction or consequence. FC Goa want errors acknowledged and handled openly.
- Appointment and assessment. How referees are picked for matches, and how their performance is graded, are opaque to clubs.
- Structured dialogue. Regular channels between clubs and the Referees’ Department, rather than ad hoc letters sent after a bad night.
- Mentoring for new officials. The letter’s concern about support for referees new to the league is on record. Promoting officials into the top flight without scaffolding is unfair to them as well as to the clubs.
The club also stressed that it wants to work with the governing body and other stakeholders to raise the standards of refereeing in the league for the future.
The “It Evens Out” Problem
The standard defence of officiating errors is that they balance out over a season. FC Goa’s position, as outlined in the brief, is that this no longer holds up. The logic is weak for three reasons:
First, errors do not distribute evenly. A stoppage-time throw-in decides a match, while a missed offside in a 4-0 win decides nothing.
Second, even if the errors did balance, the points lost would not. A penalty missed in stoppage time costs one club points that a different mistake next month cannot return. In a compact league, where playoff places can turn on a single result, one match-deciding error carries a real cost in standings, sponsor value and player careers.
Third, the argument asks clubs to accept a lottery. Sponsors, broadcasters and prospective investors price predictability. Players weighing a move to India want to know that results reflect performance. “It evens out” is an argument about fairness over time, and nobody can be compensated afterwards for a lost match.
All clubs have been riddled with referee errors
FC Goa have themselves implied this affects every club, every player and every fan who wants Indian football taken seriously, and this past week in the ISL supports their claim.
Earlier, Mohun Bagan Super Giant were denied what looked like a clear penalty against Odisha FC for a handball, and their coach responded with sarcasm. FC Goa also made a formal complaint in January 2022, seeking clarification over decisions in matches against Kerala Blasters and NorthEast United.
In 2020, the AIFF general secretary conceded there had been refereeing problems “not just this season but previously too” and asked for patience while referees were developed. That is a long time to wait.
The Structural Gap
Indian referees work under real constraints. They officiate under intense scrutiny, with limited professional pathways and little exposure to high level match volume. And the league has no effective review mechanism for decisions that replays make obvious, which means the officials have no safety net.
The 2020 argument that foreign referees are financially unsustainable still has force, so domestic development is the only long-term answer. That is why punitive blame would be counterproductive. Fining clubs for criticism, or scapegoating one referee, fixes nothing.
Technology alone will not fix it either, it still needs trained operators and clear protocols. The real work is investment in training, assessment, and communication, which needs clubs, the AIFF and the league organisers to cooperate.
What the AIFF Should Do Next
FC Goa asked for visible action, and visible action is the test. The AIFF should publish a response and a timetable. It should also commit to explaining major decisions and acknowledging clear errors, and set out how referees are appointed and assessed. Regular club-referee forums should be established, with a mentoring structure for newer officials.
Finally, it should publish a feasibility plan for video review, even a phased one. Competitive integrity cannot be restored by a letter, but a letter can force a response. The question now is whether the AIFF answers it.
What happened in FC Goa’s ISL match against Bengaluru FC?
Bengaluru FC clinched a dramatic 2-1 victory over FC Goa in the MG Indian Super League (ISL) at the Pandit Jawaharlal Nehru Stadium in Fatorda, Goa, on Friday.
What position are FC Goa in the ISL 2026-27 points table?
After their match against Bengaluru FC, FC Goa sat 6th in the ISL 2026-27 points table with 1 win, 2 draws & 1 loss from their 4 games in the season so far.
For more updates, follow Khel Now on Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, Youtube; download the Khel Now Android App or IOS App and join our community on Whatsapp & Telegram.