Top 10 players to play for both Tottenham and Chelsea
Spurs’ all-time second-highest goalscorer was scouted by Chelsea when he was 15.
In the world of football, few rivalries capture the imagination quite like the fierce North London-West London clash between Tottenham Hotspur and Chelsea. These two giants of the English game, separated by little more than a stretch of bustling city streets, have waged countless battles that have shaped the very fabric of English football. Yet, amidst the animosity and electrifying atmospheres, a select few players have dared to cross the divide, donning both the white of Spurs and the blue of Chelsea during their illustrious careers.
The likes of Jimmy Greaves, one of football’s most prolific marksmen and a true Tottenham legend, and Carlo Cudicini, the Italian goalkeeper whose composure graced both Stamford Bridge and White Hart Lane, epitomize the rare breed of footballers who have walked this contentious path. Their journeys symbolize not just talent and adaptability but also the courage to embrace the challenges of representing two clubs steeped in rivalry.
Switching allegiances between two clubs that have often battled for supremacy in league and cup competitions is no ordinary feat. It’s a journey fraught with skepticism from both sets of fans, as loyalty is questioned and every touch of the ball is scrutinized under an unforgiving spotlight.
In this feature, we delve into the extraordinary careers of the top 10 players who have had the distinction—and dare we say, audacity—to represent both Tottenham and Chelsea. From legends who cemented their names in the annals of football history to modern-day stars who navigated the emotional and professional complexities of this dual allegiance, these players have redefined what it means to thrive amid rivalry.
10. Micky Hazard
Mickey Hazard, the 5’7” central midfielder from Sunderland, carved a distinctive path in English football, earning the rare distinction of representing both Tottenham Hotspur and Chelsea with remarkable adaptability. Hazard’s journey began at Tottenham’s esteemed youth academy, where his creativity and flair saw him rise to the senior team. Over nearly a decade at White Hart Lane, he made 91 appearances and scored 13 goals, becoming a fan favourite for his technical skill and midfield vision.
In 1985, Hazard made the controversial decision to join London rivals Chelsea. Despite initial criticism, he embraced the challenge with commendable adaptability, registering 81 appearances and scoring nine goals over five years. His time at Stamford Bridge saw him lift the Full Members’ Cup and the Division 2 trophy, cementing his place in Chelsea’s history.
Following stints at Portsmouth, Hazard returned to Tottenham Hotspur in 1993, bringing his career full circle. His second spell at Spurs not only celebrated his enduring connection with the club but also underscored his loyalty to the game. After hanging up his boots, Hazard transitioned into coaching, contributing his footballing expertise to teams like Hadley and Crystal Palace. His journey from a promising youth player to a seasoned professional and mentor stands as a testament to his enduring passion for the beautiful game.
9. Scott Parker
Scott Parker, the dynamic English midfielder from Lambeth, began his footballing odyssey with Charlton Athletic, where his exceptional vision and tenacity in midfield quickly garnered attention. In 2004, Parker made a high-profile move to Chelsea. Despite showcasing glimpses of brilliance during his 15 appearances and netting a solitary goal, his opportunities became constrained with the arrival of marquee signings such as Arjen Robben and Tiago Mendes. This led to Parker seeking greener pastures, resulting in subsequent stints at Newcastle United and West Ham United, where he firmly established himself as a reliable and industrious midfield presence.
In 2011, Parker’s career took a significant turn as he joined Tottenham Hotspur, a move that was warmly welcomed by the club. In an official statement, Spurs expressed their delight in securing the services of such a seasoned professional. During his two seasons at White Hart Lane, Parker made 63 Premier League appearances, becoming a vital cog in their midfield with his leadership and work rate.
Later, Parker transitioned to Fulham, where his performances continued to exemplify his consistency and commitment. His stellar contributions to both club and country earned him the prestigious England Player of the Year award in 2011, a testament to his influence on the pitch. Parker’s journey, marked by resilience and adaptability, underscores his enduring legacy as one of England’s most respected midfielders.
8. Bobby Smith
Bobby Smith, the prolific English centre-forward from the North Riding of Yorkshire, embarked on his footballing journey with Chelsea, where he was part of the historic 1954-55 squad that clinched the First Division title. Despite his potential, Smith struggled to cement a regular starting role with the Blues, prompting his departure in 1955. He crossed London to join Tottenham Hotspur, a move that would define his legacy in English football.
At Spurs, Smith flourished, becoming an integral figure in Bill Nicholson’s legendary double-winning team of the 1960-61 season. His remarkable goal-scoring prowess saw him net 33 goals in 43 matches during that campaign, making him the top scorer for the team as they claimed both the league title and the FA Cup. Smith’s physical presence, clinical finishing, and unwavering determination epitomized Tottenham’s attacking brilliance.
To this day, Bobby Smith remains one of Tottenham Hotspur’s greatest-ever goal-scorers, sitting behind only legends like Harry Kane and Jimmy Greaves in the club’s all-time scoring charts. His contribution to Tottenham’s storied history continues to inspire generations of fans and players alike.
7. Graham Roberts
Graham Paul Roberts, the resilient English defender from Southampton, began his footballing odyssey with local clubs Southampton and Portsmouth before making a pivotal move to Tottenham Hotspur in 1980. At Spurs, Roberts became a cornerstone of the team, known for his tenacity, leadership, and defensive prowess.
Roberts played a vital role in Tottenham’s golden era, contributing significantly to their back-to-back FA Cup triumphs in 1981 and 1982. His finest moment came in 1984 when, as captain, he led Spurs to UEFA Cup glory, showcasing his indomitable spirit and guiding the team to European success. Over his memorable stint at White Hart Lane, Roberts amassed 209 appearances and netted 23 goals, leaving an indelible mark on the club’s history.
Following his success with Spurs, Roberts joined Rangers, further enhancing his reputation as a stalwart defender. In 1988, he returned to English football with Chelsea, where his commanding performances helped secure the Second Division Championship in the 1988-89 season. His exceptional displays earned him the prestigious Chelsea Player of the Year award in 1989, along with a well-deserved spot in the PFA Team of the Year for his Second Division exploits.
Also read: Top 10 players to play for both Liverpool and Everton
6. Colin Lee
Colin Lee, the versatile English midfielder from Torquay, began his footballing career with Bristol City and Torquay United before making a transformative move to Tottenham Hotspur in 1977. His arrival at Spurs was marked by an unforgettable debut, where he netted four goals against Bristol Rovers in the Football League Second Division. His stellar performance played a pivotal role in Tottenham’s promotion to the First Division that season, cementing his place in club lore. Over three seasons with Spurs, Lee made 62 appearances and scored 18 goals, showcasing his adaptability and attacking instincts.
In 1980, Lee transferred to Chelsea, where his career reached new heights. Over 185 appearances for the Blues, he found the back of the net 36 times. One of his standout moments came in the Full Members’ Cup final at Wembley in 1986, where Lee’s brace contributed to a thrilling 5-4 victory over Manchester City, earning Chelsea the trophy.
After brief stints with other clubs, including Brentford, Lee transitioned into management and coaching. He took the reins at several teams, including Watford, Wolverhampton Wanderers, and Millwall, further contributing to the game with his tactical knowledge and leadership.
5. Carlo Cudicini
Carlo Cudicini, the distinguished Italian goalkeeper from Milan, began his career with notable clubs such as AC Milan, Prato, and Lazio before embarking on a transformative journey to Chelsea in 1999. Initially joining on loan, Cudicini’s exceptional performances between the posts earned him a permanent contract, and he went on to cement his legacy as a club stalwart. Over the course of a decade, he made 141 appearances for Chelsea, showcasing remarkable reflexes and composure. His contributions during the 2001-02 season were particularly outstanding, earning him the prestigious Chelsea Player of the Year award.
In 2009, Cudicini made a free transfer to Tottenham Hotspur, seeking a new chapter in his illustrious career. He debuted for Spurs in a Premier League clash against Stoke City, eventually making 19 appearances for the North London outfit. Despite limited opportunities, his professionalism and experience were invaluable to the squad.
Cudicini later moved to the United States, joining Los Angeles Galaxy in Major League Soccer, where he continued to exhibit his trademark reliability. Beloved at Stamford Bridge and respected across the clubs he represented, Cudicini remains a cherished figure in football, celebrated for his consistency, sportsmanship, and contributions to the beautiful game.
4. Gus Poyet
Gus Poyet, the charismatic Uruguayan midfielder from Montevideo, carved an indelible mark in English football during his stints with Chelsea and Tottenham Hotspur. Joining Chelsea in 1997, Poyet quickly became a pivotal figure in the club’s midfield. Despite enduring a ligament injury that ruled him out of the 1998 Football League Cup final, he bounced back spectacularly. In the 1998-99 season, Poyet netted 14 goals, becoming Chelsea’s second-highest scorer and playing a vital role in securing a third-place finish in the Premier League.
Among his standout moments was a stunning goal in the FA Cup semi-final against Newcastle United, a tournament Chelsea ultimately won. His contributions also propelled the team to the UEFA Champions League quarter-finals, solidifying his reputation as a goal-scoring midfielder.
However, with Claudio Ranieri’s arrival and Chelsea’s transitional phase, Poyet sought new challenges and moved to Tottenham Hotspur in 2001. In his debut season at Spurs, he replicated his scoring prowess with 14 goals, helping the team reach the League Cup final, though they succumbed 2-1 to Blackburn Rovers. Over two seasons marred by injuries, Poyet still managed an impressive tally of 23 goals in 98 appearances for Spurs, earning admiration for his resilience and flair.Poyet’s career exemplified determination and adaptability, and his knack for scoring crucial goals left an enduring legacy at both clubs, cementing his status as one of the most impactful Uruguayan midfielders of his era.
3. Glenn Hoddle
Glenn Hoddle, the illustrious English midfielder from Middlesex, stands as one of Tottenham Hotspur’s most celebrated legends. A product of the Spurs academy, Hoddle joined the club at the tender age of 12, swiftly rising through the ranks to become a pivotal figure for the team. During a remarkable 12-year tenure at White Hart Lane, he made 377 appearances, scored 88 goals, and earned a reputation as one of the most technically gifted midfielders of his era. His six-foot frame, coupled with unparalleled vision and elegance on the ball, made him a maestro in midfield.
Hoddle’s brilliance earned praise from none other than Johan Cruyff, who once remarked, “I’ve heard a lot about you, but I didn’t realize how good you were until I played against you.” With Spurs, Hoddle won the FA Cup twice, along with the FA Charity Shield and the UEFA Cup, further solidifying his legacy.
However, in a decision that sent shockwaves through Spurs fans, Hoddle moved to Chelsea in 1993 as a player. His spell at Stamford Bridge was brief and largely uneventful on the pitch, as he departed in 1996 without making a senior appearance for the Blues. Despite this, his stature as one of the most gifted footballers to have been part of both London clubs remains undisputed.
2. William Gallas
William Eric Gallas, the towering 5’11” French defender from Asnières-sur-Seine, carved a unique legacy in English football by becoming the first player to don the jerseys of three fierce London rivals: Chelsea, Arsenal, and Tottenham Hotspur. Gallas began his journey with clubs like Caen and Marseille before joining Chelsea in 2001, where he quickly became a cornerstone of the team’s defence.
At Chelsea, he formed formidable centre-back partnerships first with Marcel Desailly and later with John Terry. The Terry-Gallas duo was particularly impenetrable, achieving a remarkable 16-game streak without conceding a single goal. During his five-year tenure at Stamford Bridge, Gallas played an instrumental role in Chelsea’s back-to-back Premier League triumphs under José Mourinho, earning him a spot in the PFA Team of the Year for the 2005-06 season.
In a move that shook the footballing world, Gallas transferred to Arsenal in 2006, famously taking the iconic No. 10 shirt vacated by Dennis Bergkamp, a rarity for a defender. As captain, he was a vocal leader, though his tenure at Arsenal was marked by moments of brilliance and controversy. In 2010, Gallas made another audacious decision by signing with Tottenham Hotspur, becoming the first player to appear for Chelsea, Arsenal, and Spurs. Despite frequent injuries, he remained a respected figure at White Hart Lane, providing leadership and experience to the squad. Gallas once boldly claimed that Spurs had the potential to win the Premier League, showcasing his unwavering confidence in his team.
1. Jimmy Greaves
James Peter Greaves, more affectionately known as Jimmy Greaves, remains a towering figure in English football, renowned for his clinical finishing and exceptional goal-scoring prowess. Hailing from Danbury, Greaves began his illustrious career at Chelsea, where his immense potential was quickly recognized. Scouted by the club’s Jimmy Thompson, Greaves made an immediate impact at just 17 years old, scoring on his debut in a 1-1 draw against Tottenham Hotspur at White Hart Lane.
His ball control, confidence, and natural positional intelligence set him apart, with the News Chronicle lauding him for qualities usually reserved for seasoned professionals. Over four years at Chelsea, he amassed an impressive 124 goals in just over a century of appearances, establishing himself as one of the brightest talents of his generation. After a brief spell at AC Milan, Greaves made a defining move to Tottenham Hotspur in 1961, joining a club fresh off a historic achievement, having become the first team in England to secure the First Division and FA Cup double in the 20th century.
At Spurs, Greaves truly cemented his legendary status. He became an integral part of the team, helping Spurs lift the FA Cup twice, the FA Charity Shield, and the European Cup Winners’ Cup. His remarkable goal-scoring feats were pivotal to Spurs’ success, and his contribution was recognized when he finished third in the Ballon d’Or rankings for 1963, a testament to his extraordinary impact that year.
Even today, Jimmy Greaves’ name is etched into the annals of Tottenham Hotspur’s history. Greaves’ clinical finishing and his remarkable ability to find the back of the net remain an inspiration, forever intertwined with the very fabric of Tottenham Hotspur’s rich footballing heritage.
For more updates, follow Khel Now on Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram; download the Khel Now Android App or IOS App and join our community on Telegram.
- Bologna vs Borussia Dortmund Prediction, lineups, betting tips & odds
- Benfica vs Barcelona Prediction, lineups, betting tips & odds
- Which teams have won three consecutive Premier League matches against Manchester United at Old Trafford?
- Liverpool vs Lille Prediction, lineups, betting tips & odds
- Dani Olmo ruled out of Barcelona's next match due to new injury
- Kerala Sports Minister denies dates of Lionel Messi & Argentina's visit to India
- Top 15 best players to have graduated from Barcelona's La Masia academy
- Top three teams with most wins against Manchester United in Premier League
- Countries with only one player to feature in Premier League history
- Top 10 players to play for both Juventus and Inter Milan