Which WWE star can replace Finn Balor in the Judgment Day?

(Courtesy : Getty)
The Judgment Day turned on Finn Balor during last week’s WWE Raw.
Finn Balor refused to help his stablemate, Dominik Mysterio, and even stopped JD McDonagh from getting involved. The decision ultimately led to Dirty Dom losing the Intercontinental Championship, an outcome which led to Balor’s exit from the stable.
After losing the title, Dirty Dom on the March 9 show called out Balor, and what followed was the entire Judgment Day faction turning their back on Balor. Even JD McDonagh turned on Finn, with the rest of the faction, including Liv Morgan and Raquel Rodriguez, joining in the beatdown of their former stablemate.
Dirty Dom and the rest of the Judgment Day booted out Balor after he refused to help his own stablemate. The exit has also led them to be a member short, especially as Roxanne Perez is also out of action as she is recovering from surgery.
While Perez will eventually return, the faction still needs to recruit one member to replace Balor, and here we will take a look at four WWE stars who can replace Finn in the Judgment Day faction.
4. Grayson Waller

Since parting ways with Austin Theory, Grayson Waller was determined to drop a dead weight, and under the New Day’s vision, he might be able to achieve success. However, Waller has only been used by the New Day to further their interest.
Furthermore, Waller has not been featured in any major storyline or feud in recent times, and joining the highly influential faction could not only revive his character but also help him get major matches and ultimately title shots.
Also Read: Top five WWE stars who could team up with Finn Balor against The Judgment Day
3. Kit Wilson

Similar to Grayson Waller, Kit Wilson is also currently on a singles run, as his tag partner, Elton Prince, is out of action for a long time due to a serious neck injury. While Wison’s new theme song has made him instantly recognizable among fans, the lack of proper feud or matches has meant no real career growth for him.
A move to Monday Night Raw and joining the Judgment Day could help elevate Wilson even more and a mid-card title reign will also solidify his place on the roster.
2. El Grande Americano

El Grande Americano is currently locked in a feud with “Original” El Grande Americano over who the real Americano is, and despite being accompanied by Rayo and Bravo Americano, El Grande has mostly been unable to counter the OG.
El Grande joining forces with the Judgment Day will help him in his feud against the OG, and in turn, Americano can also help Dirty Dom against Balor. El Grande and Dominik have already worked together for a brief period of time and can revive the partnership for short-term gains.
1. Rusev

Since his return last year, WWE has not consistently positioned Rusev in a strong long-term storyline, aside from his feud with Sheamus. Recently, he suffered a decisive and swift defeat against Oba Femi, which further impacted his momentum and standing on the roster.
Although Rusev typically competes as a singles star, joining a faction could open the door for him to become involved in multiple high-profile rivalries and potentially serve as the group’s enforcer, giving him renewed relevance and a clearer direction.
Why was Finn Balor kicked out of the Judgment Day?
Finn Balor was kicked out of the faction by Dominik Mysterio during the March 9, 2026, episode of WWE RAW, after refusing to help or even let JD McDonagh help Dominik retain the Intercontinental title.
Who are the current members of the Judgment Day?
Dominik Mysterio, Liv Morgan, JD McDonagh, Raquel Rodriguez & Roxanne Perez are the current members of the faction.
For more updates, follow Khel Now Wrestling on Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram; download the Khel Now Android App or IOS App and join our community on Telegram & Whatsapp.
Abhijit Singh is a budding sports journalist with over three years of experience in the field, and a photographer capturing stories through his lens since 2018. With a background in philosophy and political science, he brings a thoughtful, analytical edge to his reporting where every word is guided by curiosity and intent. Whether he's capturing the emotion of a moment or unpacking the deeper narratives within the game, Abhijit’s work is rooted in insight and passion. When he’s not covering sports, he’s often exploring new ideas through reading, traveling or just procrastinating.